Talk About Money: Seagate loss will hurt local business
by Mark Rosenberg
Jul 08, 2010 | 1310 views | 13 13 comments | 13 13 recommendations | email to a friend | print
Whose wallets will be lightened next year when Seagate moves its headquarters — and 400-plus jobs — out of Scotts Valley? Not Seagate employees’. They’ll still have jobs, because the move does not include layoffs.

No, the financial hurt of this move will be felt by surrounding businesses: restaurants, stores and others.

“It’s going to hit us really hard,” said Jorge Aragon, owner of the two Los Gallos taquerias in Scotts Valley.

He said customers wearing Seagate badges have been among his most loyal, and he’s seen a drop in business after job cuts in recent years.

“Some of them came in to say goodbye after they were laid off,” Aragon said.

Even though fewer than half of the disk-drive maker’s Scotts Valley employees live in the city, many of them go to lunch, have drinks, do their grocery shopping and see doctors in town.

Jason Clements, general manager of Scotts Valley Market, says lots of Seagate workers pick up lunch at his store’s deli or do their shopping before they commute home to Santa Clara Valley.

“Now, all those dollars will be spent in San Jose,” he said.

Luon Nguyen, office manager for dentist Wandy Tsai, says Tsai’s practice will be hurt directly and indirectly.

“If Seagate employees move their families out of Scotts Valley, we lose patients,” he said. “And if local businesses slow down and their incomes drop, one of the places where people sometimes feel they can cut back is on dentistry.”

For the owner of Malone’s Grille, the loss of Seagate’s headquarters recalls 30 years of memories.

“When we opened in 1980, we had a lot of loggers and truckers coming in,” recalled Patty Malone. “Then, all of a sudden, these suits start coming in, saying, ‘Hey, we opened a company down the street.’”

Malone’s became the after-work hangout for many Seagate workers.

“People would come in at 5 p.m. and stay till 11,” she said. “They’d have office parties here; they’d meet people here and end up getting married.”

Malone’s was mentioned in a Time magazine article as the watering hole of Seagate co-founder Al Shugart.

“Seagate put Scotts Valley on the map,” Malone said.

Seagate executives even had a phone installed at Malone’s with a direct line to the company’s facility in Singapore. When the Loma Prieta earthquake struck at 5:04 p.m. Oct. 17, 1989, Seagate workers who lived in Santa Clara Valley hung out at Malone’s, sharing sandwiches and drinks, until they could figure out how to get home.

“This was really a family spot for Seagate people,” Malone said.

Another bar and restaurant owner, Jason Revino of Jia Tella’s and JT’s Next Door, says he’s also saddened by the Seagate decision. But he hopes the City Council will entice another big employer to move in.

“I have confidence in (Mayor) Jim Reed and the gang,” Revino said. “They have a business mindset. They brought Easton Bell Helmets here, with 175 jobs. They’ve got a year to see if they can lure another big business here.”

Mark Rosenberg is an investment consultant for Financial West Group in Scotts Valley, a member of FINRA and SIPC. He can be reached at 439-9910 or mrosenberg@fwg.com.
Comments
(13)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
failReports
|
July 26, 2010
Where in the search is the thread on the school issue? Redenbacher and Bustichi should be found under keyword searches for that, or is this a pattern of "failing to report" the news there too? or worse - covering the tracks of political allies of Reed? It's all connected.
Woweee
|
July 26, 2010
Is this true? Let us see the records Reed or resign. How can we trust you if you can't show your involvement with the paper and as a Council Member. Editor, you should do the same or are you going to sit there and cover for your contributing writer (Reed). Conflict of interest and trust are issues of integrity, white smiles and photo pops can't cover the truth. Grand Jury now...
LinksOfTruth
|
July 26, 2010
Google around, you will find the links between the Banner, Reed as sports editor, the current editor as student sports at the high school, the previous owner of the paper, the core of the city council at the lions club and linked relationships throughout the county. Ever wonder why Vic Marani shows up from Capitola? All roads to Sacramento go through Scotts Valley. Even the political screen runners like from San Francisco now SV post the Banner as their tool of effect. If you bothered to make a chart like I have, you would get an eye full, and I promise that the reason why the city is in trouble is because the fox is guarding the hen house. And the paper gets its calling orders - hey editor post your personal phone lost and lets see how close your calls match the stories, time for a grand jury. Old information doesn't lie, lets see unless you are hiding something....time for freedom of information request with Reed so close to the phone while writing for the paper and as past editor.

Show us or we will know you are hiding. Show us all the phone records.

We need new leadership.
Editor Reed
|
July 26, 2010
Why would the Banner fail to report the news about Title II? The Sentinel even ran the story twice. If you think that the Banner isn't political guess again. The Banner has very close ties to many on the City Council. Don't forget that Mayor Jim Reed was the editor of the Press Banner just a few years ago before he became an insurance salesman.
SoooooRight
|
July 25, 2010
Just like they ran Sessions out of town by harassing them for having - god forbid- Sales. Yea, has right, the council forced them to dip into the city funds to even accommodate a sale from an industrial park. Wow, that's just a simple retailer. Imagine high tech lack of relationship and understanding. Sorry, we DO need new leadership.
Attracted by Donna
|
July 25, 2010
Yeah, right! Probably gave every prospective employer a taste of local hospitality. Now they are swarming to base their business here. Oh, they do not like being attacked and not welcome in HER town? Magnetic personality. You BetchA
sounds like frank
|
July 24, 2010
Hay frank we cansee its you again bashing the council I can not wait toexpose you foer the lieing council canidate you are hurry up and file like how you have tried tosue the city
YourKiddingRight
|
July 24, 2010
Do you thing a paper as economically weak with as inexperienced editor will make ANY waves agaist the council? Not like the paper dosent already have a long record of burying unflattering stories or a pattern of editorial abuse. Like anytime someone stands up, they have their face in the front page so everyone knows...Thems the ones...the community would be better served if they just reported the truth and that way the companies who are here would recognize a fair-minded government and maybe think this a place worth staying.
Banner asleep
|
July 23, 2010
Where is the Banner story about Title II being sold because of unpaid debts and the news that Scotts Valley is now being forced to foreclose on the property to collect $400k in back taxes? The Sentinel reported the story on Monday the 19th and again on Tuesday July 20th. Is the Banner asleep at the wheel or are you just mum on the story because it might be perceived as another negative on the City Council?
Bad Plan
|
July 11, 2010
I'm sure most of you have noticed that the homes here in Scotts Valley aren't cheap. How are we supposed to be able to live here with low-wage shopping center jobs? I guess we'd better start building low-income housing to match our low income jobs.

John Galt
|
July 11, 2010
Starnesville
Make Helmets Instead
|
July 11, 2010
"What makes you so sure that Jim Reed and the rest of the City Council can attract high paying jobs and high tech to Scotts Valley?"

Obviously they can't, they're all leaving or already left a long time ago. What I think is funny is how the chamber of commerce tries to portrait SV as a little high tech bubble in the mountains. What a joke. What they can attract is low wage shopping center jobs. And we all know who gets those since Americans don't want to do those jobs.

No High Tech left
|
July 09, 2010
Mark,

What makes you so sure that Jim Reed and the rest of the City Council can attract high paying jobs and high tech to Scotts Valley? Even before Seagate's planned move Scotts Valley had more than 500,000 sq feet of vacant office space. Almost all of that space was once occupied by high paying tech companies. Why should we suddenly have confidence that this council understands who to attract and what it will take get and keep them? This council seem focused on low paying retail and manufacturing. The division of helmet manufacturer Bell wasn't recruited by this council. They came to Scotts Valley only after they ran out of space in Santa Cruz. The building they now occupy was previously left vacant when software firm SurfControl left Scotts Valley for southern California. Sadly not a single member of our City Council has any affiliation with the high tech industry. Mayor Jim Reed is an insurance salesman who doesn't even work in Scotts Valley, Former Mayor Johnson is another insurance salesman, former Mayor Bustichi is a builder, Donna Lind is a retired SV policewoman and I don't know if Stephany Aguilar ever worked in private industry is also appears to be without any high tech background. Face it, this Council doesn't have the the experience or the connections to attract high paying jobs to Scotts Valley. If you disagree perhaps you can name a high tech company of any size that this council has recruited or managed to keep in Scotts Valley. This list of such firms that have left is too long to post.


We encourage your online comments in this public forum, but please keep them respectful and constructive. This is not a forum for personal attacks, libelous statements, profanity or racist slurs. Readers may report such inappropriate comments by e-mailing the editor at pbeditor@pressbanner.com.