Letters: Cooperation is better for Scotts Valley schools
by Susan Silver, superintendent of Scotts Valley Unified School Distric
Feb 11, 2010 | 1440 views | 12 12 comments | 10 10 recommendations | email to a friend | print
EDITOR,

I was disappointed and puzzled by Dene Bustichi’s commentary last week (“Yes, Dr. Silver, we do care about our schools,” Feb. 5) following his attendance at a community meeting held by the Scotts Valley Unified School District board and administration. The purpose of the meeting was to explain to the public the effect of the governor’s proposed budget on public education in general and SVUSD in particular.

During the meeting, audience members asked a variety of questions. Mr. Bustichi may have misunderstood but certainly misrepresented responses I made, taking them out of context and drawing erroneous conclusions. The commentary seemed to be a personal attack, rather than an analysis of, or commentary on, the difficult issues facing our school district.

SVUSD, already a low-funded district, will definitely experience further cuts that may ultimately hurt programs and services for our students. This is a time for the community to come together in a sincere attempt to understand the issues, have open and inclusive dialogue and come to a community consensus for action.

I trust that Mr. Bustichi is involved in community service for the same reason that I have dedicated my professional career to public education — to add to the quality of life of the people we have chosen to serve. In these difficult times, it is imperative that we take a positive approach, working together to support the young people in our community.

I invite Mr. Bustichi join us in a spirit of cooperation. Together, we can achieve far more.

Comments
(12)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
susie christensen
|
February 13, 2010
its is laughable when susan silver talks about having "inclusive dialogue", " working together to support the young people in our community" and working "in a spirit of cooperation".

Several years ago when SVUSD paid for a FCMAT report on how to save money and one of the suggestions was to work with parents and include them in discussions and team buliding opportunities......never happened....and yes, we the cititens paid for this report that dr. silver choose to not pay attention to....

throw in several no confidence votes by the teachers and I'd say we have a real problem here.
Heard it before
|
February 13, 2010
And as usual, the anti-silver clan resorts to name calling and 3rd party accusations. Somebody got their feelings hurt a few years ago and the world stops. Maybe next we'll hear how the HS construction was botched 15 years ago so we should never try building anything ever again. Let's live in the present, people.
MS in BD
|
February 13, 2010
Obviously SV Parent has a personal issue with Ms. Silver. Your childish attacks on anyone that disagrees with you do nothing to support your view. Instead they make me question your rationality.
sv parent
|
February 13, 2010
Obviously, not new to SV is a Board Member that will not stand up to Susan Silver. Susan Silver is condescending and demeaning not only to teachers, but parents too.

Not new to SV
|
February 13, 2010
valleyparents -- you make my point exactly. Teachers deciding on their own how to spend their professional development time is like a company providing an independent study hour as training to its employees. What is it about some teachers that they can't take instruction? Some of the best teachers my kids have had here in SV are lifelong learners. They relish the chance to learn something new that can help them take their students to a higher level or take them there in a more engaging way. I want teachers who willingly put themself in environments that challenge them to think in new ways. Because that's what I want them to teach my kids, and kids will know whether you live what you teach.

Oh, and I was at the meeting where Dr. Silver mentioned that she was from over the hill. She said her hometown supported bond measures for their schools. Ours did not. Simple statement of fact. There was no comparison. Geez, half the town gets their feelings hurt over a misquote. Must have been a slow news week.
svparent
|
February 13, 2010
Wow. Those are brutal words. Definitely reflects a lack of concern for pulic education and a commplete disdain for our teachers. Have you ever worked for a company before. Ever had a boss. Did you agree with everything your boss did. Did you tear up when you were asked to do a job you didn't like. Please.
valleyparents
|
February 13, 2010
Examples of Dr. Silver's former words:

"Are we a good school district? Eh. Do we have good kids and good teachers? Yeah, probably. But are we GREAT? Not really." - this was her speech the day before school started to all of her staff in attempt to inspire them to achieve higher last year.

She has also said that she doesn't live here but that her town is more supportive than ours. I strongly disagree.

Our teachers were not opposed to professional development - they already had it when Dr. Silver arrived. What they were opposed to is the idea that someone else should be able to tell them how to best spend their professional development time.
sv parent
|
February 12, 2010
WOW!! Not new to SV must be from another planet!
Not new to SV
|
February 12, 2010
Don't take SV Parent's word for it. Dr. Silver drew the wrath of some teachers when she first arrived by suggesting that professional development would be good for them. When they objected, she insisted. The result has been increased performance and improved comraderie amongst most of the teaching staff, but grumbling and name calling by those who can't embrace the truly professional notion that a professional should always seek to improve themselves. The tide turned about two years ago, but reputations always lag and laggards always talk.
new to sv
|
February 12, 2010
As a recent transplant, I don't know the history. SV Parent, what are the issues with Dr. Silver? I keep hearing these comments that she doesn't care about the teachers, but how does this manifest itself? What has she done that has created this feeling? We've been in two other districts and there always seems to be a bit of a push-pull between the teachers (and unions)and the Super and Board, especially in California where financing has been tough for many years. (Don't get me started on special ed financing.) I would like to hear what the issue is. Is it her style or substance?
sv parent
|
February 12, 2010
The reason that Susan Silver is puzzled is because she just doesn't get it. Her dedication to public education is questionable , since she has no regard for the teachers that make SV schools successful.
Banner politics
|
February 12, 2010
For a week the Press Banner kept Dene Bustichi's rant on Dr. Silver in the top opinion article position. When Dr. Silver comments in reply her post is place near the bottom of the opinion section. Just another example of the Banner playing politics. Shame on the Banner.


We encourage your online comments in this public forum, but please keep them respectful and constructive. This is not a forum for personal attacks, libelous statements, profanity or racist slurs. Readers may report such inappropriate comments by e-mailing the editor at pbeditor@pressbanner.com.