Letter: Accident doesn’t merit lawsuit
by Mark Senko, Santa Cruz
Nov 19, 2009 | 955 views | 5 5 comments | 9 9 recommendations | email to a friend | print
EDITOR,

I just read the story about Allie Pomianowski, who is paralyzed after a tragic automobile accident on Mount Hermon Road (“Paralyzed driver to sue county after crash,” Page 7, Nov. 13). She and her family have my sympathies. But suing the county (i.e., the taxpayers in the county) goes beyond reason.

On their own blog site (referenced in the article), they said: “Posted by Allie at 2:07 PM on Monday, May 4, 2009 Dear Family & Friends on April 7 Allie was in a car accident that changed our lives forever. It was a rainy day and an unfortunate accident in which no one was to blame” (sic).

Living in the mountains, I can say that Mount Hermon is not a dangerous road by any means or comparison. I suspect the inexperienced driver on the wet road who lost control and crossed the center line is at fault, if anyone is.

You have my sympathy, not my wallet.

Comments
(5)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
Next to die is Jeep
|
December 30, 2009
jerk in his black primer junker out of ben lomond.

Playing chicken with every car and truck.

Someones daughter was with him.

jeep cherokee box, black wheels, stick shift. no spare on back, bbcap.

f88888 stupid. pre airbag, excessive speed, tailgating, punk wimpy, high school age.

Do not let your kid ride with this POS, or they will die soon.
Honesty always
|
December 11, 2009
I agree too, lawsuits have become ridiculous (meaning the people who try them with egregious intentions). On two different occasions, people have tried to sue me, and have lost. The first, went through five attorney's before that person gave up, and settled: It was a fraudulent claim anyway, so when it came time to collect their money, they ended up with practically nothing. By the time the second one happened, I was so pissed off over the long process of worry - whole thing could have been avoided on their part - that I reported that person to the county for violations, and it resulted in home foreclosure. Now I'm in law school, 'cause I'm sick of this stuff and it's a waste of tax money some of these juror's I've seen, can't award a reasonable amount in civil court. Don't mess with the bull you'll get the horns.
ALRUI
|
December 04, 2009
Hey "Join" take your shameless plug elsewhere, the roads ARE safe if the posted speed limits/caution signs/etc. are followed and you take your vehicle dynamics/condition into account. The thing that makes the roads unsafe is drivers who dont heed these rules. Actually what you & your pet group are going to do by making the roads "feel" safe is to make people NOT pay attention and cause more accidents & the associated injuries & deaths. There are studies that prove so-called "safe" roads are not safe at all. Heres a good article from Popular Mechanics that explains things in a simple manner:

http://www.popularmechanics.com/science/research/4308670.html

B.C. resident
|
December 01, 2009
I couldn't agree more with this letter.

I, too, feel terrible for the tragic accident and the family it impacts but, this country is just a little too sue crazy.

The article states Allie is an 07 S.V.H. graduate. It would seem to me that she ought to be familiar with the road, no? If she graduated in 07 she's most likely an inexperienced driver, no? Article states she lost control of her car, the road didn't do anything to cause her loss of control.

So, some poor county worker is coming the other way and has the horrific site of an out-of-control car heading for them. Well, maybe that person was speeding, let's sue the county! Heck they have deep pockets, right?

What if that was Allie's next door neighbor driving that other car? Would that change the lawsuit any?
Join
|
November 22, 2009
Join the movement for Scenic Route designation and bring money to the city and county for road safety. Please raise awareness on road safety and this issue. They have not done everything they can do to make the feeder roads safe.


We encourage your online comments in this public forum, but please keep them respectful and constructive. This is not a forum for personal attacks, libelous statements, profanity or racist slurs. Readers may report such inappropriate comments by e-mailing the editor at pbeditor@pressbanner.com.